“Why should the majority respect the minority?” Ali Badri Zaini, the head of the East Java chapter of the Islamic Dakwah Forum..
…….
“The minority should respect the majority. The minister is [talking] nonsense. The Islamic faithful in East Java will never do as he instructs.”
He said it was considered customary for all warung to at least close off their façade with a tarp so as not to tempt those who were fasting.
Wow!
Temptation!?!
—————-
Lukman
——–
This arrogant bigot is up in arms because Minister of Religious Affairs Lukman last week tweeted an appeal for MUTUAL tolerance. His words, on the need for mutual respect and understanding for those who were not fasting, echoed the late President Gus Dur.
—-

‘We Muslims should fast with respect for those not fasting.’ -A REAL Muslim scholar, the late President Gus Dur
Regardless of the specific fasting issue, it’s hard to see how anyone could respect such a rabid ranter as Ali Badri Zaini.
But he is only one of many enemies of tolerance here.
Jazuli Jawani, a legislator from the Prosperous Justice Party (PKS), said Lukman’s call for those who were fasting to respect those who were not was highly regrettable.
——————————————————-
- Jazuli argued that it was only natural for those “carrying out the faith” to be granted greater respect than those who were not…
http://thejakartaglobe.beritasatu.com/news/ministers-call-mutual-respect-ramadan-elicits-conservative-backlash/
No it’s not. Those who are fasting only have to show a bit of self-discipline.
——–
Those who are not fasting risk the brutal intimidation we often feature here, meted out by fanatic savages like the IslamoNazi FPI.
And how dare any member of the PKS talk about any statement from anyone being highly regrettable – has Jazuli forgotten his party leader’s sickening ode to the mass-murder Osama Bin Laden? Written AFTER 9/11?
=========
Anis Matta
-=———————————–
mass-murdering beast Bin Laden
————————–
That’s regrettable!
—
But we can dismiss Zainal and Jazuli as outlandish extremists, singing from the same song-sheet as the IslamoNazis…...non-Muslim citizens who aren’t fasting, Zainal added, should take care not to disturb the sanctity of Ramadan. Especially eating and drinking in front of others at places open to public view… http://nasional.news.viva.co.id/news/read/638009/fpi-janji-tak-lakukan-sweeping-saat-ramadhan That’s another Zainal, Zainal Abidin Petir, FPI Gauleiter in Central Java.
Nevertheless, the same triumphalist tripe has just emerged from the Deputy Governor of Jakarta echoes this intolerance – Djarot Saiful Hidayat also urged restaurants to install curtains on their windows during Ramadhan in order to respect those who are fasting. –http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2015/06/15/jakarta-administration-and-residents-prepare-ramadhan.html
Respect again. Beause they’re fasting, everyone else has to hide behind a curtain? And bars have to be closed? Because fasters might be tempted?
What’s self-denial worth in moral merit, if there’s not a scent or sight of anything one’s supposed to be denying oneself?
And how contemptuous these Islamist extremists are, of those they purport to represent!
Not all Muslims fast, by any means – it’s up to them, after all – but of those who do, it bespeaks a commitment that they choose to make.
Not eating during daylight hours is no serious hardship, but going thirsty, in this climate, is no fun. Yet they undertake to do so, and a lot of them stick to it. I can admire such tenacity.
But it’s a personal choice. Their personal choice. It should not impinge on anyone else.
Do bleating blow-hards like the Zainals really think that fasters will be subverted by the sight of me or anyone else sitting in my fave warteg having a plate of perkadel?
00

00
Sure, if I held out my plate enticingly, like one of Odysseus’ sirens, urging some poor faster to share my delight.
Tempting then like that would be mean, but nobody does that.
If some fasters walk by a bar and – inexplicably! – choose to peer nosily into its dimly-lit interior, and catch sight of me with a cold Bintang? Is either Zainal seriously saying the devout will at once cast off their self-control and rush in to join me in a binge?
- Sure, if I sent out some lightly-clad bar-girl, extolling the joys of a cool quaff on a torrid arvo.
Tempting them like that would be mean, but nobody’s going to do that.
The killjoys’ case is codswallop.
And they know it!
000000

0000
Their only aim is to make minorities bow down. As Ali Badri Zainal, more honestly than the rest, indeed, puts it!
“Why Should the Majority Respect the Minority?”
But there’s always a silver lining in these stories, and in this one it’s an off-the-cuff remakr by one of Lukman’s critics, a legislator from ex-President SBY’s party.
—-

—
Khatibul Umam Wiranu, a member of the Democratic Party, accused Lukman of trying to curry popular support through the media through statements like his call for mutual respect. .
Which means that Khatibul, at least, perceives that’ popular support’ accrues to leaders who publicly espouse decency, and not to intolerant undesirables.
Like this:
Like Loading...
Silviati 15:27 on May 21, 2017 Permalink |
You say it very well, Ross, how mean they are with stupid rules when the only rule should be rule we make for ourselves.
This is because fasting is CHOOSE not to eat, not order by scholar who think he knows God better then we do,
Same like stupid curtain.to make us not see eating. If we CHOOSE not to eat then we do not need stupid curtain to make us keep our promise to us.
Stupid curtain.and stupid scholar and stupid politician like so many in Aceh who will pretend to be holy but still corrupt and steal money from poor people.
I will fast because I can and I will and not because they make me.
You and everyone can fast or not, Indonesia is NOT Iran or Arab Saudi.
LikeLike